Wednesday, May 4, 2011

The Bear Jew: Gabe Carimi

Chicago has had its share of great athletes, Michael Jordan, Frank Thomas, and Stan Mikita to name a few. The Bears have probably the richest of the Chicago teams with players like Walter Payton, Gayle Sayers, and Dick Butkus. But it has been a while since any Chicago team has had a great Jewish athlete. The Cubs had Ken Holtzman and Steve Stone but besides those two it has been hard for Chicagoans to rally around a top Jewish star. The one Chicago Jewish athlete that has Hall of Fame status is Sid Luckman. Luckman retired in 1950 and since Chicago Jews have been searching. And with the 29th in the 2011 NFL Draft the wait might have ended. The Chicago Bears selected Gabe Carimi out of the University of Wisconsin.
The last two NFL drafts have seen three Jewish football players drafted. In 2010 Tampa Bay took Erik Lorig in the 7th round. The other pick was Taylor Mays who was a projected first round pick. After getting snubbed by his own college coach Pete Carroll, Mays fell to the second round. But this year Carimi was selected in round number one. Jewish football fans have a player to finally cheer. Over the last few years there have been a bunch of up and coming Jewish athletes in other sports including Jordan Farmar, Kevin Youkilis, and Mike Cammalleri. But Carimi comes in immediately and is arguably the top Jewish NFLer. His numbers will not be flashy and he won’t be catching touchdowns, but he has the opportunity and potential to be a perennial Pro Bowler.
Carimi will play for an offensive line that is anchored by Olin Kruetz. He has one objective in the Mike Martz style offensive; protect Jay Cutler. The Bears have invested a lot of time and money in their quarterback and have done a poor job giving him time to throw the ball. So, Carimi needs to keep Cutler off his back and allow him to throw touchdowns.
In college Carimi won the 2010 Outland Trophy for the nations top interior lineman. He had 49 starts at left tackle and played in the 2011 Rose Bowl. He was also a unanimous selection 2010 Consensus All-American, and the Big Ten Offensive Lineman of the Year.
That is what he has done on the field but in the synagogue he has been much more impressive. He grew up in a Reform synagogue where he was Bar Mitzvahed at Temple Beth-El in Madison. He had a Bar Mitzvah project that helped Habitat for Humanity. While in High School he helped in his synagogue’s Hebrew School. In 2007 Yom Kippur landed on a Saturday (game day). Carimi fasted up until an hour before the game. When asked if Yom Kippur lands on a NFL Sunday, he has already checked and says it is not going to happen.
He is not only Jewish but he cares about his religion. Caring brings Jews more pride than just playing sports. Yes, we love Sandy Koufax for being Jewish, but we hold him on a pedestal for not playing on Yom Kippur. We love Omri Casspi for playing basketball but we cheer for him more for embracing the Jewish community. And we follow Yuri Foreman for being a Champion, but we love him more because he is going to be a Rabbi. Carimi is not just another Jewish player; he will be a leader on the field and in the Jewish world.
We as Jews should celebrate this first round draft pick. Not just Bears fans, but Jews everywhere. Carimi is a public figure, one that embraces his Yiddishkite and can be a role model for young Jews everywhere. I know I will be watching him on a weekly basis, which is made easier by him wearing Blue and Orange. So welcome “Bear Jew” and Bear Down!


  1. First I would like to welcome Gabe to the great city of Chicago which is a much warmer place to play than the frozen tundra up north in Green Bay!!

    For anyone who doesn’t know this—YOM KIPPUR NEVER FALLS ON A SUNDAY (Sunday night—YES, but not Sunday day)!! The Jewish calendar is permanently set so that Yom Kippur cannot fall on a Friday or Sunday. This was done so we wouldn’t go from a fast day directly into Shabbos/Shabbat (you cannot prepare on a fast day for Shabbos)or go from Shabbos/Shabbat directly into a fast day. Yom Kippur can fall on a Shabbos/Shabbat. Gabe—you have nothing to worry about unless you are scheduled to play a game on a Sunday night or Monday night which happens to be Yom Kippur (my advice is for the NFL not to schedule Bear games on Yom Kippur or for Jay Cutler to put on his sprinting shoes)!!

    BTW—Chicago has has MANY Jewish pro-athletes. Steve Stone played for both the White Sox and the north side team (my mother taught me its better not to say anything bad about anyone). Besides Stone the White Sox have had nearly a Minyan of Jewish pitchers Ross Baumgarten,Scott Schoenweiss, Steve Rosenberg, Scott Radinsky and most recently Aaron Poreda. And don’t forget DH Ron Blomberg.

    The Black Hawks had a few goalies Mike Veisor and Murray Bannerman (I am not 100% sure about Murray). While the Bulls are owned by a syndicate of mostly Jewish owners, I cannot recall a Jew playing for the team during the regular season.

    And, I just found out that Antonio Garay, a defensive tackle for the Chicago Bears is Jewish too. Imagine this TWO JEWISH BEARS!!

  2. Well said, Jeremy. I wouldn't have minded seeing Carimi drafted by my Jets, but I wish him well in Chicago. He does have a good chance to be a real good one. It's just a bit of a shame that he doesn't play a flashier position, as offensive lineman, no matter how good they are, tend to get lost in the shuffle a bit. One of these days I wold love to see a bonafide Jewish star QB in the NFL. I have read all about Sid Luckman's greatness, but still I would like to live through an era where we see a great Jewish QB. I guess you can say that Jay Fiedler and Sage Rosenfels were/are pretty decent in their own right, but to be honest, neither is much above average, if that.